01 Dec 2018 15:02:53
Philly
Macdonald, Raffl, Sanheim, 2nd round pick

Toronto:
Nylander, Brown, Gardiner or Dermot


1.) 01 Dec 2018
01 Dec 2018 15:25:06
That package is weak for Nylander. Really bad for Nylander and brown and absolutely terrible if adding Gardiner or dermott. Especially dermott. Troll I’m assuming? Lol.


2.) 01 Dec 2018
01 Dec 2018 16:31:07
You are under valuing Sanheim. Potential top pairing d-man is well worth nylander who has a limited market because of salary demands. Raffl is a former 20 goal man vety strong on the puck. You must be a leafs fan are ya? Macdonald is in there to help free up $$ to sign Nylander hence the 2nd rd pick.


3.) 01 Dec 2018
01 Dec 2018 17:16:44
You have to ask if Jim's a Leafs fan? Ya must be new around here lol. Welcome aboard,
Your going to have to add., Sanheim may be good, but I don't think he tips the scale enough for that package. Raffl, I nothing special
How about making a way that Simmonds is going to Toronto with a D man for Nylander?


4.) 01 Dec 2018
01 Dec 2018 17:17:13
Brown is a younger raffl, very hard on the puck as well, also a former 20 goal scorer and a Babcock favourite. I’d keep brown over him but call that a wash for simplificstion. You say Sanheim is worth Nylander alone, I strongly disagree as do most people on here I’m sure, but again, call that a wash if you want to. A cap dump and a 2nd for Gardiner, our 2nd best Dman, in a year we are trying to win? Or for dermott, a young player that has shown elite mobility and is going to be replacing Gardiner after the season?! Lol not a chance that’s close. IF the first 2 comparables are equal, which they’re not, it’s still bad for leafs.


5.) 01 Dec 2018
01 Dec 2018 17:50:48
That’s a gross package.

Nolan Patrick, Oscar Lindholm And Sanhiem for Horton, Lievo, Dermotte And 2nd?

Patrick=Nylander IMO.


6.) 01 Dec 2018
01 Dec 2018 21:15:44
Know leafs fans want a boat load for nylander but not going to get it. going to sign for too much, or get traded for less then market value. Teams don't want a pretty unproven player that sits out rather then being on a potential contender. kane, gaudreau, McKinnon all waaaaay better players and signed in 6-6.5 range on second contract. Nobody wants nylander at his asking price or would be signed or traded by now.


7.) 01 Dec 2018
01 Dec 2018 21:56:24
Patrick = Nylander 😂.


8.) 02 Dec 2018
02 Dec 2018 07:01:51
Shoots, gaidreau and Mackinnon were signed 2 off seasons ago but you’re right, they’re better players and signed in that range. The Kane one was $6.3 mill signed 8 offseasons ago. That’s a bit of a stretch to use lol.


9.) 02 Dec 2018
02 Dec 2018 16:43:46
The difference in timing between Nylanders contract and Kane’s, is the same length as Kanes 2nd contract and Jason spezzas! Lol that’s going a little further back than fair.


10.) 02 Dec 2018
02 Dec 2018 16:45:25
I was criticized for comparing draisatl to mackinnon and scheifeles deals because they were 14 months apart or whatever, but Nylanders overpaid because he makes more that Kane signed for 8 years prior haha 😂.