NHL Rumors mobile

NHL Talk mobile

Post NHL rumors

Latest Montreal Canadiens Trade Rumors

30 Jan 2015 16:38:17
Habs should send Eller, Gilbert, Thomas and the 2016 draft 2nd rounder obtained from Buff (for Gorges) to Arizona for Vemette & Michalek (both pending UFAs)

Boris Bagel



 

 

30 Jan 2015 07:12:25
MTL: markov
Avs: oreilly

MTL: 1 st round 2015
TOR: franson

Pacioretty-plekanek-parenteau
Oreilly-desharnais-sekac
Galchenyuk-Eller-Gallagher
Prust-malhotra-weise
Bournival

Subban-beaulieu
franson-emelin
Gilbert-gonchar
Weaver
Price/tokarski

Avs needs a solid D to get in the playoffs MTL needs a young top 6 forward to be a Stanley cup contender the next five years, leafs are tanking and franson is not resigning there
Thoughts?

habs


O'Reilly for a retirement package?

Chirp


As a UFA rental, franson isn't worth a 1st rounder, maybe a 3rd rounder

Boris Bagel


@Boris - even if he had some term left, he's not worth a 1st IMO

JUICE61


Too much for a pending UFA. Just take a look at what teams got for their pending UFA last season, it was way less than that.

justgivemethepuck


Bagels you are so wrong. A team making a playoff push would give up 1st for Franson. However I can see a prospect and a 2nd or 3rd being the return the Leafs get.

MG69


30 Jan 2015 18:52:35
Tomas Kaberle a pending ufa was traded for a first round draft pick conditional second and a good prospect.

Franson is a 26 years old, and a very good offensive D man I am sure Franson could get more than a third or 2nd rounder. Not saying Franson will get the same return as Kaberle but maybe a good prospect and a decent pick.

returnofrealisticleafsfan



 

 

30 Jan 2015 05:54:00
Now montreal is trying to build the next russian army :chucky ,markov, emelin,gonchar, scherback coming soon, don't get surprise if yakupov get trade to Montréal soon and maybe even trade for malkin , and with This it Will bring back kovalchuck to sign for Montréal st a low cost!
Ok i'm joking for some part

Could habs use the fact that pens are with a lot of injury and trade for malkin by giving a lot of starter , prospect and pics?the trade would have to include no pk no price no forward from the russian army but all the other are avaible

Secondly habs beat ny 1-0 well it seam that with a healty price the Rangers would have probably bow down during the east final last year

Montrealfinest


I would take out pacciorety untouchable I could see Eller beuliue 2 1st Gallagher and a mccanron and throwerc

Habsfan11


30 Jan 2015 07:53:26
Yeah sure. Scraps, Scraps, Scraps, Scraps and Scraps for a superstar entering his prime.

(I know it's not all scraps but compared to Malkin it is)

Draisaitl_94



 

 

29 Jan 2015 19:24:09
Mtl: 3rd, 6th
Tor: Tyler Biggs

I feel that if the Habs give him the ice time and opportunity he deserves, as well as good management backing him and believing in him, I think he can finally develop and make the jump to the big club and be given the chance on another team. Low risk, high reward for Montreal in a player who could be a great player, or just worth what the Habs traded for him, peanuts

Thoughts??

piccante1


Just a 6th is enough

Boris Bagel


I think it would be more along the lines of what Montreal got for Leblanc. 4th-6th rounder, with some condition

StaalingForTime



 

 

29 Jan 2015 19:10:56
Carolina:Alexander Semin(40% Retained) , Andrej Sekera

Montreal:Alexei Emelin, Christian Thomas, 2nd round pick (2016 from Buffalo)

habsfan22


Semin! why? Habs better off dressing Thomas or Andrighetto

Boris Bagel


So MTL takes on a cash dump to bench for the next couple years just to get Sekera? Thank god you're not a GM. Horrible idea

Chirp



 

 

29 Jan 2015 14:04:12
To Montreal: Jagr. Zidlicky. To New Jersey: Emelin, mtl eats 10% of remaining salary Jacob De la rose. Christian Thomas

donnieg_17



 

 

28 Jan 2015 01:57:33
MON: Emelin, 4th

TOR: Franson, conditional 6th**

**Leafs make playoffs

guys don't bash me for this if it isn't fair I don't even know franson's value LOL but whatever I don't follow the Leafs that much

pksubban76


Dont worry post anything you want most of the people here are angry leaf fans who bash any person who make a trade that is not favorable to there team! Not a bad trade considering the fact that franson would probable re sign with Montréal in the off season

Montrealfinest


Emelin isn't the sort of player TOR is looking for. And I don't see them taking back salary either.

THEGR81


Toronto is better off either trying to resign Franson or trading him for picks and or prospects , Emelin's contract is horrible , maybe if montreal retained 35% of his salary until his contract expires , then Toronto might do this.

steamer


Too much for Franson, one for one, no 4th rounder is OK

Boris Bagel


Montreal can keep thier cheap shot artist , maybe try trading him to Boston , he'll fit right in over there.

steamer



 

 

28 Jan 2015 01:38:45
EDM: Eberle

MTL: Gallagher,Emelin,3rdRD 2015



Edmonton's Lines:

Hall-RNH-Gallagher

Yak-Roy-Pouliot

Purcell-Gordon-Hendricks

Fraser-Lander-Klinkhammer

iamthebestone


I'd rather keep Gallagher and see how good he's gunna get. And Eberle is just another small guy that doesn't like to go in corners

Habfan2


I wouldn't say that. He's not a big impact player like hall but he does get roughly the same amount of points

Oilers_11


Edmonton doesn't want Emelin and his contract , change him to Beaulieu then maybe Edmonton considers.

steamer


Habs better off with Gallagher

Boris Bagel



 

 

27 Jan 2015 02:18:35
Montreal is in the hunt for a top 6 winger I have a few trades they could do with edmonton.

Taylor hall for Eller, Emelin, beaulie, 2nd round pick and a c rated prospect

Or
Eberle for beaulie, Eller and bryan allen and a 3rd

or Yak for Pa parnutue

Who adds or takes away

Habsfan11


Your trades are horrible man parenteau for yakupov? yeah so mac t just thinks to himself I think ill trade a 20 year old former 1st overall pick on a entry level deal to montreal for an aging player with the same production who got a bad contract for another season after this one.oh yeah and the fact parenteau is battling concussion problems makes him even more desirable. then phaneuf for yandle AND A PICK if this was possible don't you think nonis would have already jumped at this full speed.taylor hall for eller and scraps?come on man your better then that.put some actual thought into it

hab.


IMO MacTavish would accept that trade. Do you mean a pick from Dalton Thrower, Morgan Ellis or Jeremy Gregoire would be examples of "C" rated prospects?

sbr2017


I think Edmonton doesn't do any of those they want more quality players that can be difference makers for them and your providing the with all of montreals expendable pieces. In order to get players like a Hall or Eberle edmonton would probably want something from montreal that would be a little harder to give up.

TMLeafs


Wow, MacT would be fired. 3 times.

StaalingForTime


I read some where to get eberle it would take eller or Deharnis and a young defender and a pick to get him

Habsfan11


Horrible trades.

steamer


@Habsfan11 , where did you read that, The Montreal Gazette? lol

steamer


Oils need to add

Boris Bagel



 

 

26 Jan 2015 23:51:32
If richards clears

Emelin, parenteau, 3rd for richards, williams

Or

Emelin, desharnais for richards, williams


Gives LA a defenseman that can fit their physical style and gives montreal a better looking attack and allows tinordi to get called up

Also LA probably won't be able to give williams a raise and sign him so they also get a younger forward at the same price williams costs now

Pacioretty. Plekanec. Williams
Galchenyuk. Richards. Gallagher
Bournival Eller. Sekac
Prust. Malhotra. Wiese

Markov. Subban
Beaulieu. Gonchar
Tinordi. Gilbert

Montreal would still need to look for some defensive help imo

Cannavina


L.A would want plekanec for Williams.

steamer



 

 

26 Jan 2015 22:38:54
montreal looking for top 6 winger
Edmonton trades hall 7th round pick

Montreal trades eller, emelin, beuliue, and mccaron and a 3rd round pick and throw in pa parnutue

Or cheaper option they could do is
Eberle for Eller bueliu and 3rd and 5th round pick

Or pa paurntue for yak reunite him with Galyenchuck

Who needs to add or take away

Habsfan11


Yes yes no. IMO EDM would want more for Yakupov

sbr2017


The 7th rounder makes it all ok

StaalingForTime


In all honesty I think Edmonton declines. There isn't much of value coming back at all in those deals. Packages headlined by emelin/Eller won't get you hall/eberle

jbs32


27 Jan 2015 13:04:24
Quantity =/= Quality
If you think you're getting Hall without Galchenyuk and/or Fucale going the other way, you're nuts.

Draisaitl_94


If Montreal wants Hall they can start with Galchenyuk and add. If Montreal wants Eberle they can start with Gallagher and add. Do you see what I'm getting at. You have to give something of value to get something of value.

steamer



 

 

26 Jan 2015 16:00:43
Let me take a shot at improving montreals top 6

MTL: Alexei Emelin

OTT: Alex Chiasson

Montreal might end up with too many forwards and ottawa may not want emelin (I don't blame them lol)
Tell me what you think! Who adds?

Soobydoo


Ottawa is looking for more scoring up front and are willing to give up some of their dman because they have a lot. This trade really doesn't work for them.

TMLeafs


That is true. How's the value though? Far off?

Soobydoo


Chiasson is younger and has way more upside, Emelin is overrated , Montreal adds.

steamer


Chiasson is more of a 3rd line winger, only on pace for 30 pts.

Boris Bagel



 

 

25 Jan 2015 19:34:26
With all the rumors surrounding the leafs. I believe that they should trade for picks and prospects and may be one or two key players. Here are my thoughts on this.


to Habs: Lupul
to Leafs: Andrighetto and 3rd 2015

Leafs move salary and get a B level prospect and pick
As for the Habs they get a player that has been a point a game player when health, Lupul would be a great upgrade for the first line with Pach's and Planc. This would help the Habs greatly since they are making a great push for the Stanley cup.

to Av's Phaneuf, Holland Finn
to Leafs O'rielly

I know that Av"s are taking on Dion salary but a change of scenery might get him back on track, he was a plus 17 at one point. Plus leafs give Holland and fin a good third line center that would be any upgrade from Berrie that is gone at the and of the season, plus a good young d-man.

Leafs get a much needed center

To NYY Kadri
To Leafs Rayn Pulock and Micheal Dal Colle

Here me out on this trade Kadri would be a great fit with Isl's playing with John again would bring him back to life, they had great chemistry in London. Also this would help them make a really run in the playoffs

Leafs get back some blues chip prospect in the rebuilding process.

To Wings Franson and Santeralli
Leafs Tatar

Wings get a top 4 d-man that can help on the back end and who has one hell of a shot from the point. Also Santeralli would help up front in the absent of Tatar

Leafs get rid of 20 million in cap and bring back 9 million in return. That is a good start in the rebuilding process.

And my be just my be they can a top 5 pick in this years draft.

These are just my thought on the rebuilding process.
Like to here what u think on these trades

Fan4Life

Fan4Life


25 Jan 2015 20:27:29
thats what lupul is worth, but I can't see MTL doing it since they sent out a lot of salary this year to make room for future contracts.

again, you're likely pretty close on the COL one, but I just don't see it happening.

dont think NYI will move dal colle, he seems to have a pretty high ceiling

ido like that franson one and it does seem to make sense, maybe add a conditional pick from DET depending on if franson signgs with them or not.

Shankar


You don't actually think Kadri is worth 2 solid prospects, do you?! LOL!

You overvalue the leafs players in all these proposals, but especially that Kadri one.

Chirp


Love all of them but the kadri one. I think we should kadri and just get a new number 1 centre and trade bozak.

paolozza


26 Jan 2015 21:56:21
Um, Dal Colle alone is worth more than Kadri.
Also, the Isles already have like 27 centers on their roster.

Draisaitl_94


Big no from Habs

Boris Bagel



 

 

25 Jan 2015 02:36:30
Hans trade pa parnute,2nd,3rd beuliue Gilbert, deshrnis and a b rated prospect andbuffalo For Myers gives montreal size for playoffs,Stewart replaces pa hogeson replace deshrnis mike weber and a 5th round pick Gives a cap dump for Montreal and size gives buffalo a chance for mcdavid get a young stud defender in beuliue and gets some picks for the rebuild who adds what do u think

Habsfan11


One of the most confusing things I have ever tried to read

hab.


Sorry it was on my phone what do you think

Habsfan11


25 Jan 2015 08:54:26
For everyone wondering, that's the trade he proposes:

MON trades: Parenteau, Beaulieu, Gilbert, Desharnais, 2nd, 3rd, B-prospect

BUF trades: Myers, Stewart, Hodgson, Mike Weber, 5th

Just a general thing: People need to learn what B-prospects are. I guess many are rather talking C-prospects when they say B. The only Habs B prospect if at all would probably be Fucale.

Draisaitl_94


Drasitil what would McCarron,de la rose,hudon,reway,andregetto and tinordi be classified as in your opinion

hab.


25 Jan 2015 13:08:57
I guess C mostly.
Ask sbr2017, he made a list a few days ago (not his opinion, but he got the ratings from somewhere). And I can tell you, the guys listed as B prospects there are far above these guys you just mentioned.

Draisaitl_94


So do u think this trade could work

Habsfan11


Easy no from Buffalo.

steamer


Draisatil but I guess namestinkov, koekoek, erne and kucherov are all A prospects.and we all know you wouldn't trade vasilevski for mcdavid and eichel.lolol

hab.


25 Jan 2015 18:27:35
Kucherov and Namestnikov aren't even prospects anymore.
Koekkoek and Erne are B or B- prospects I'd guess, I didn't look it up, tho.
So a bit better than the MTL prospects you listed above. Tell me you wouldn't trade Reway, McCarron or so for Erne or Koekkoek. If, you're lying.
So what's your problem?

Oh and I never said I wouldn't trade Vasi for McDavid. I just think he's the real deal and our future franchise G.

Draisaitl_94


25 Jan 2015 18:29:09
Tampa's A prospects are Drouin (if you still count him) and Vasilevski, I'd say.

Draisaitl_94


IMO an A prospect is definitely a top line 6 projection, B prospect possible top 6 projection, C long shot top 6 projection, probably a bottom 6 player. The list order came from ESPN 2014-2015 prospects, I added the letters. If I gave Drouin and Ekblad an A rating, what does one give McDavid? A++++++
A-:
1 Jonathan Drouin LW Tampa Bay Lightning QMJHL 1
2 Aaron Ekblad D Florida Panthers OHL IN
B+:
3 Sam Bennett C Calgary Flames OHL IN
4 William Nylander RW Toronto Maple Leafs SHL IN
5 Sam Reinhart C Buffalo Sabres WHL IN
6 Nikolaj Ehlers LW Winnipeg Jets QMJHL IN
7 Kevin Fiala LW Nashville Predators SHL IN
8 Leon Draisaitl C Edmonton Oilers WHL IN
9 Michael Dal Colle LW New York Islanders OHL IN
10 Evgeny Kuznetsov C Washington Capitals NHL 4
11 Filip Forsberg RW Nashville Predators NHL 13
12 Teuvo Teravainen C Chicago Blackhawks NHL 21
13 Haydn Fleury D Carolina Hurricanes WHL IN
B
14 Curtis Lazar RW Ottawa Senators WHL HM
15 Kasperi Kapanen RW Pittsburgh Penguins Liiga IN
16 Brandon Gormley D Arizona Coyotes NHL 19
17 Mikhail Grigorenko C Buffalo Sabres NHL 7
18 Josh Morrissey D Winnipeg Jets AHL 80
19 Bo Horvat C Vancouver Canucks OHL 28
20 Griffin Reinhart D New York Islanders WHL 34
21 Nikita Zadorov D Buffalo Sabres NHL 32
22 Andre Burakovsky LW Washington Capitals OHL 26
23 Darnell Nurse D Edmonton Oilers AHL 20
24 Nicolas Petan C Winnipeg Jets WHL NR
25 Pavel Buchnevich RW New York Rangers KHL 69
26 Jake Virtanen RW Vancouver Canucks WHL IN
27 Max Domi C Arizona Coyotes OHL 16
28 Alexander Wennberg C Columbus Blue Jackets SHL 31
29 Derrick Pouliot D Pittsburgh Penguins WHL 68
30 Sonny Milano LW Columbus Blue Jackets USHL IN
31 Hunter Shinkaruk C Vancouver Canucks WHL 22
32 Jakub Vrana LW Washington Capitals SHL IN
33 Anthony Mantha LW Detroit Red Wings QMJHL 86
B-
34 Jacob de la Rose LW Montreal Canadiens SHL 95
35 Robby Fabbri C St. Louis Blues OHL IN
36 David Pastrnak RW Boston Bruins SHL-2 IN
37 Riley Barber RW Washington Capitals NCAA NR
38 Brendan Perlini LW Arizona Coyotes USHL IN
39 Rickard Rakell C Anaheim Ducks NHL 44
40 Mirco Mueller D San Jose Sharks AHL 94
41 Ville Pokka D New York Islanders Liiga NR
42 Johnny Gaudreau LW Calgary Flames NHL 50
43 Dmitrij Jaskin LW St. Louis Blues NHL 51
44 Hudson Fasching RW Buffalo Sabres NCAA NR
45 Mathew Dumba D Minnesota Wild NHL 39
46 Oscar Klefbom D Edmonton Oilers NHL 17
47 Chris Bigras D Colorado Avalanche OHL NR
48 Mark Stone RW Ottawa Senators NHL 99
49 Vincent Trocheck C Florida Panthers NHL 58
50 Ryan Spooner C Boston Bruins NHL 36
51 J.T. Compher C Buffalo Sabres NCAA 91

sbr2017


If you guys are arguing about who has better prospects /Habs vs Tampa. No brainer , Tampa.

steamer


I wouldn't trade mccarron for erne or koekoek

hab.


McCarron played on the 4th line last year in the "O". He is a bust

leaffan


Yeah but let me guess tyler biggs is still a great prospect.mccarron was terrible last season but has really improved this year not only on offense but is being labeled as one of the best 2way forwards in the league.he may never be a great nhl player but he will make it.he will at least be as good as brian boyle.

hab.


26 Jan 2015 22:00:52
Well, that's what I mean. Look at the names listed as B prospects. People often use the term B prospect basically as a throw in in deals. Looking at the names, these guys are everything but that.
That's what I wanted to say. The names listed there are far above Rewar, Andrighetto, McCarron or whoever. Again, I think Fucale is the only Habs prospect B or better.

I still have no idea why you personally had to attack me, hab, but k.
Oh and if you wouldn't trade McCarron for Erne and Koekkoek, good thing you're not a GM.

Draisaitl_94


Great list! not!
Gaudreau is #42 but might win NHL rookie of the year, while about 20 of those guys ahead of him will likely never play more 30 games in the NHL

Boris Bagel


Biggs, he can't even make the AHL!

Boris Bagel


@bagel , Draisaitl94 didn't come up with the players listed above ESPN did. Draisaitl94 the reason your being attacked is cause these are delusional habs fans and you didn't have ten of thier prospects on the list,we should all know by now , the habs have the best prospects ever!

steamer


Steamer, learn how to read: I know who made list, I was making fun the list not the poster

Boris Bagel


Funny cause the way that I see it is that This list is no good first of cause scherback is a way bether prospect then delarose and is not there!
Speaking of bust steamer your leafs Gauthier is a big one I rather have Mccaron then him anytime!

Montrealfinest


@Montrealfinest, I never mentioned anything about a bust and am not a leafs fan. Your 0 for 2 Montrealsworst .

steamer


Yeah Nice try but your sarcasm on the habs prospect make it look like it! Yeah like were going to believe that you only talk about the leafs its ok u don't have to be ashame of your team! Now leave Boris baigel alone I think that he should say watherver he want without being critise each time he make a comment! Now I can take your non sense because I don't care what the response on my post but he can maybe be affected by you're response

Montrealfinest



 

 

24 Jan 2015 19:09:20
Leafs trying to tank toronto trades franson to montreal for 2nd round pick near deadline if he isn't traded

Habsfan11


I don't see toronto & Montreal making a trade. Franson could probably fetch more though

StaalingForTime


24 Jan 2015 20:07:48
no thank you from TOR, Andrew Macdonald got a 2nd, 3rd and prospect last year, and franson is a better player than macdonald.

Shankar


Instead of a 2nd, how about a 4th rounder & Gilbert

Boris Bagel


Buf: Georges

Tor: franson

Montrealfinest


24 Jan 2015 23:22:40
Oh, they`re not TRYING to tank.

seabass2011


Lol at the deal line they will get more than a 2nd ,more like a late first and something

DAWSON67


And u think we can't get more then that foe franson?? U must be a habs fan.

paolozza


Right at the deadline rest assure someone will pay at least a 1st for him if not more

paolozza


You guys say he must be a habs fan because he thinks of this as fair but everyone that is not a Toronto fan sees Franson not equal to a first rounder. So LOL you must be. Toronto fan.

ProDepth


It's not out of the realm of possibility(a TO/MTL trade). Not sure if it's for a 2nd or not. Really depends on how badly MTL needs a d-man.

There are a Lot of playoff bound teams that likely need Franson more and therefore will be willing to pay more.

THEGR81


I agree teams will offer more but 2015 first round picks aren't just tossed away.

ProDepth


25 Jan 2015 20:36:03
neither are top 4 right handed defensemen making under 1.5 mil (pro-rated) that are just entering the prime of their career.

Shankar


^ depends on who's making the trade - teams who think they have a shot at the cup finals (conference finals really) likely don't value those later 1st nearly as much as something in the middle of the round.

THEGR81


Leafs need to add

Boris Bagel


Montreal needs to add.

steamer



 

 

24 Jan 2015 18:56:48
How about Montreal trades Emelin, 3rd a 4th round pick for Mike Richards retain 1 million in cap just wondering what u guys think because la needs a defence men and montreal has a lot of them and it takes some of the cap off la

Habsfan11


Not like there's a logjam at centre for Montreal or anything.

StaalingForTime


Richards, no thanks, not even for a 5th rounder and retained salary. he's done. a 4th liner at best

Boris Bagel


Montreal has no need for Mike Richards at all.

habsfan22



 

 

23 Jan 2015 20:01:35
Just some thoughts I had as we approach the trade deadline

Leafs trade Lupul retain roughly 2 mil and a draft pick
Jets trade Bogo
Jets have a good surplus of defenders and Toronto is lacking.

Sens trade Phillips to either Islanders or Flames to help solidify their respective D cores.
Can't see the price being more then a pick and below average prospect

Buffalo trades Myers and Stafford
Avs trade ROR and Holden and either a 2nd or 3rd
This trade is more then likely a long shot. ROR would be a nice #2 behind Reinhart in the future but then again Buffalo could have Mcdavid or Eichel in the next several months

Leafs trade Franson & draft pick
Red Wings trade Jurco & Kindl

Also I'm not a huge habs fan but I would love to see jagr play in Montreal. Maybe for a prospect and pick

Thoughts on any of the trade idea above?

Drownedfish


I will probably be in the minority and IMO all of the trades are reasonably fair, so sure.

sbr2017


The leafs retaining salary is never a good option. The mess their in is in small part to them retaining salary.
Then it opens the door when teams come calling for the likes of Kessel and Phaneuf wanting them to take on some more of the salary like they did with this proposed Lupul deal.

BizzyBee


So Bogosian would cost Toronto roughly 7.14 million for the next 3 seasons? that's terrible. Leafs should not retain any salary in a lupul trade

THEGR81


23 Jan 2015 23:39:30
no way WPG would do that, and its actually good becuase retainign 2 mil on lupul and makinig bogo a 7 million dollar defenseman is a horrible idea.

Shankar


24 Jan 2015 09:06:45
How does WPG has a surplus of D's? At least atm half of their D corps is injured.
Oh, and the value is obviously off. Not going to get a young top 4 D for an aging always injured wing

Draisaitl_94



 

 

23 Jan 2015 17:52:23
Montreal:
3rd Round Pick 2015
D Brett Lernout


Edmonton:
Jeff Petry

Eliasson_57


Overpayment by Habs, prospect or the pick not both, also, not convinced Petry is much of an upgrade for Habs, better off to look elsewhere for a D rental

Boris Bagel



 

 

23 Jan 2015 08:46:57
MTL: T. Plekanec, J. Sekac, A. Emelin, G. Pateryn, 2nd rd 2015

for

NJ: A. Henrique, M. Ryder, E. Gelinas, A. Larsson, 5th rd 2015

DahL82


This won't make the Habs better

Boris Bagel


How about eller and 2nd for henirique

Habsfan11


That's better for Habs, but would the aging Devils want to trade one of their younger players right now?

Boris Bagel



 

 

23 Jan 2015 07:50:08
MTL: P.A. Parenteau, D. Desharnais, S. Andrighetto, G. Pateryn, 3rd rd 2015

for

NJ: J. Jagr, S. Bernier, A. Larsson, S. Matteau, 5th rd 2015

DahL82


This trade is workable for both sides

Boris Bagel


Jersey loses this trade.

steamer



 

 

22 Jan 2015 17:31:27
MTL: Atkinson
CBJ: Thrower

habsfan4life


Why would Habs do this? doesn't really help them now or for the future

Boris Bagel



 

 

22 Jan 2015 12:10:31
I am re-posting a trade because it will time out today.

To Montreal Taylor Hall
To Edmonton Alex Galchenyuk

Hall after 3 years, Galchenyuk up to the all star break

Galchenyuk 158 34 55 89 +8
Hall 171 65 80 145 -7

Yup Galchenyuk is FAR better. Hall is only 2 years older than Galchenyuk, not enough to even comment about age difference.

Career Hall and Pacioretty
Pacioretty 364 128 123 251
Hall 287 103 151 254

So many remarkable comments.  Just saying what would Hall stats look like if he had Subban & Markov on defense and Price in the nets?  IMO he would have more points and a better +/-.  Pacioretty better than Hall.  OK you are right!  It is so obvious how could I have missed it.

gretzkyghost


It's a lot easier for a winger to develop then a center. That's my 2 cents.

Soobydoo


Ya because price helped a lot of habs to get more points this season.

Cd1


Actually CD1 when you know there an eraser in net to wipe out your mistakes, it does allow the offense to take more chances, but my comment was more in reference to the +/- stat.

gretzkyghost


What's your point?

benn14


@benn14, who are you asking?

gretzkyghost


@gretzkyghost you. I don't get why you posted this?

benn14


@Benn because I think the trade makes both teams better. MTL still has 3 centers and EDM needs a center. The bonus would be if Yakopuv would return to his rockie level or better.

gretzkyghost


The logistics don't work. Pacioretty is our #1 Lw. He earned that

HABSWIN


I think centers hold more value then wingers. They have to be able to distribute to get the puck to their wingers, they have to have a strong 2 way game on the back check, they have to be able to win faceoffs to keep puck possession, I think they just have all around more responsibility.

Not saying wingers like hall aren't valuable because they are but if you look at all the past cup winners they have had a superstar center that eats up a lot of minutes and plays an all around strong game. Crosby/ Malkin, Toews, Kopitar, Zetterberg, Bergeron/ Krejci just to name a few. For how young Galchenyuk is he's shown a lot of potential so I can't see montreal trading him.

Teams seem more willing to trade wingers as RNH probably won't be traded instead they are looking to trade Eberle and Hall. Same with the leafs if Kessel was a center there is no way they talk about trading him.

TMLeafs


23 Jan 2015 00:44:00
i don't understand this at all?

are you proposing a hall for paccioretty swap I don't see the point in MTL doing it, if that's what you're prosposing. if you're saying a galchenyuk for hall trade then you wayyy for off. maybe galchenyuk + 1st + fucale.

Shankar


Shankar I have to desagree galchenyuk Will be a much more complete player in the years too come compare too hall who is all offense! Plus we got pacioretty so I rather have a rw instead of hall but not for galchenyuk!

Montrealfinest


Right now, you couldn't get Hall for Galchenyuk, forget that. Maybe if Galchenyuk finally breaks out, then it turns. But right now. The Oilers would be dumb to trade Hall for Galchenyuk straight up.

benn14


Thanks, Hall has proven himself to be a top 10 performer. Most of the comments seem to reject the trade because Gacheyuk has proven he COULD BE a top 10 performer. I will not post again.

gretzkyghost


@gretzkyghost
i think the problem is that hall has more value now their is no question about that but montreal drafted galchenyuk and they hold more value in him then anyone else would. They are also one of the better teams in the east and galchenyuk is a big part of that so why go make a blockbuster trade now. It wouldn't make much sense for them considering he is their number one center of the future.

TMLeafs


Big No from Habs

Boris Bagel



 

 

22 Jan 2015 06:35:56
Chi: Sharp
Mtl: Plekanec, Andregetto, 2nd

Kings: 2nd
Mtl: Emelin

Pacioretty-Galchenyuk-Gallagher
Sharp-Desharnais-Parenteau
Bournival-Eller-Sekac
Prust-Malhotra-Weise

Markov-Subban
Gonchar-Gilbert
Beaulieu-Weaver

Price
Tokarski

UnbelievableTrades


22 Jan 2015 07:06:57
I'm pretty sure LA would do that trade in a heartbeat. But it doesn't make sense for Montreal.

Titties


22 Jan 2015 07:41:29
Mtl would never get rid of Plekanec who is their best C

ltpato


Re: Chicago trade, big no from Habs, Pleks is their number 2 scorer and most consistent C.
Re: Kings trade: Habs would take this in a minute except Kings couldn't fit his albatross of a contract under their cap. Plus Emelin has a no trade clause and is playing horribly. Habs might be able to get rid of him but only with his permission and they'll have to keep some of his salary or take on another team's bad contract.

cdigdawg



 

 

22 Jan 2015 06:29:55
Just saw a trade from habs to Colorado
Im going to upgrade it so that habs get a bether player then oreilly

Hab: emelin,andrigetho and 1st round pick of 2016,eller

For

Avs: duchenne

Montrealfinest


Horrible. no from colorado easily

TMLeafs


22 Jan 2015 09:36:06
Start with Galchenyuk for Duchene.

Draisaitl_94


"I'm going to upgrade it so that Habs get a better player than O'reilly"

Well, can't say you lied, but this trade is atrocious. Duchene has far more value than Ryan O'reilly

Captain Nutjob



 

 

22 Jan 2015 01:28:23
Montreal:

-emelin
-andrighetto
-second round pick

Colorado:

-O'Reilly

bezz


Generous offer by Habs

Boris Bagel


Way too much for big o

Montrealfinest


That's the price, allthough I doubt MTL would do it.

benn14


Habs would make that trade in a heartbeat, except Emelin has a no trade clause. O Reilly will be looking for big bucks next contract so he is a dangerous guy to give up too much for.

cdigdawg


Take out the 2nd and it gets done. Habs then call up Tinordi for the 3rd pairing or make another move for a vet D (UFA rental)

Boris Bagel


O'Reilly is a great 2 way player , you won't see him in a habs jersey for these table scraps.

steamer


If O'Reilly is so great, why are Avs trying to dump him?

Boris Bagel


@bagel , it's a business, Aves will try to trade him to get better not worse, this trade makes them worse , Andrighetto is a C prospect at best and I a long shot at making the Nhl, Emelin is playing like garbage and is garbage and a late 2nd for one of the better 2 way forwards in the league who is young and had more points than any hab last year , take off your rose colored horse blinds.

steamer



 

 

We take no responsibility for the accuracy or otherwise of published nhl rumors

Copyright mobile.nhl-trade-rumors.com All Rights Reserved

.