18 Jun 2014 06:57:46
Toronto sends phaneuf & Trevor Smith to
New York Islanders
For Griffin Reinhart & 2014 1st round pick 5th overall

1.) 18 Jun 2014
Absolutly not from Isles. Reinhart and most likely Dal Colle provide more value to the isles than Pahnuef and Smith.

It has already been stated that Reinhart will not be traded. So unless the return is so unbelievably could that it could not be passed up this would never happen.

2.) 18 Jun 2014
Good lord that trade is awful for the isles, doesn't help them at all

3.) 18 Jun 2014
Rather have Reinhart than Phaneuf. Nobody even knows who Trevor Smith is.

4.) 18 Jun 2014
And TOR fans ask why I don't like most of the trades they're proposing.

5.) 18 Jun 2014
Rumor had it phaneuf to San Jose not sure for what thought

6.) 18 Jun 2014
This is a posted for the more educated fans who look up the prospects to know who Trevor Smith is. He was with the marlies when they took the texas stars to 7 games in the west AHL playoffs. Who just won the calder cup in 5 games against st john's.

7.) 18 Jun 2014
Still a fifth and a fourth overall pick isn't enough for phaneuf who is really a top 4 d, and a good prospect whos potential is max second line, prob third

8.) 18 Jun 2014
Maybe you need the education bskiff. Trevor Smith is a 29 year player that has only played a short amount of time in the NHL, I would not call that a prospect but a career minor league. He has no value what so ever in a trade.

In fact Isles already had him, and let him go.

9.) 18 Jun 2014
Smith is not a prospect. He is an average AHLer and 4th line NHLer at best. He has little to no value whatsoever