Current Avatar:
No Avatar image uploaded
No Avatar image uploaded
NHL Trade Rumors Member Posts
Quiet Guy's Profile
No Profile Picture uploaded
Quiet Guy's Posts and Other Poster's Replies To Quiet Guy's Posts
To Quiet Guy's last 5 rumours posts
To Quiet Guy's last 5 rumour replies
Quiet Guy's rumours posts with other poster's replies to Quiet Guy's rumours posts
16 Sep 2024 17:33:05
To Oilers - Liljegren
To Leafs - 3rd rounder
With Kane going on LTIR they could absorb the contact. Apparently they are looking for an RD.
1.) 18 Sep 2024 02:00:09
Why would the leafs have any interest in moving debatably their best RHD.
2.) 19 Sep 2024 03:04:52
Blues got broberg for a 2nd.
3.) 21 Sep 2024 06:15:20
@redwing Broberg is worse, overpaid and a LHD. He has shown nothing in the NHL.
27 Jul 2024 13:32:14
Laine and Kent Johnson and a 2nd for Marner. Nothing retained on Laine.
1.) 28 Jul 2024 03:30:10
That’s an awful lot for one year of Marner, especially since CLB is rebuilding and needs prospects and picks to build around, not pending UFA’s that can’t help a rebuild.
CLB hands up.
2.) 28 Jul 2024 20:10:35
OK. so what if it's a sign and trade do they give more? Laine and his contract is a negative remember.
3.) 29 Jul 2024 07:48:16
You are 100% about Laine’s value, but he is attracting a lot of trade interest by teams apparently. (I wouldn’t be in on that deal though. )
Marner is only 27, but he’s the wrong age for a rebuilding team like CLB. I doubt he agrees to a sign and trade since he’d forego a shot at unrestricted free agency, which is every players hard-earned right.
I think Marner would be better served with a veteran core that sets the tone for him to follow, rather than him being expected to be a leader to a young and impressionable team like CLB will be growing in the years to come. I just don’t see a fit with CLB at all.
4.) 29 Jul 2024 19:05:33
@Chickenfoot I think you’re partially wrong. The fact Columbus went out and traded for Provonov and Severson then signed Monahan shows they aren’t rebuilding. On paper they actually have a deep team with a few very underrated players like Danforth who may be the best 4th liner in the league. For the right player I think they’d move futures for them.
With that being said I think Marner would be the absolute last player they’d target. They have Guadreau signed long term who while not as good is very similar to him offensively. A team with both Guadreau and Marner being payed big money is not a team that’s built to win.
I think Laine is worth a flyer on for a mid pick for a team like San Jose or Chicago but not the leafs who are trying to contend. Kent and a 2nd for Marner isn’t outrageous. I don’t think Kent has developed as expected. I’m not saying he’s a bust but I think he caps out as a 1 dimensional 70 point guy. Maybe something like a little bit better Thomas Tatar mixed with Athanasiou with Jasper Bratt as a celling.
5.) 30 Jul 2024 13:26:00
VB - this is the most diplomatically written post I’ve seen from you, and I give you props for that?
Your points are as valid as anyone’s on this, and I hear what you’re saying regarding the signing of Monahan.
My own thoughts are that the Monahan signals two things:
- he’s great at setting the tone for young players, as he did in MTL, while making everyone accountable and professional in their approach.
- signing Monahan also may help them see a better return from Gaudreau, who is untradable as-is, but Monahan may help him find his game.
05 Jun 2024 17:35:34
Marner and Liljegren for Hronek and Garland.
1.) 05 Jun 2024 18:39:55
Great trade for Vancouver not Toronto.
2.) 05 Jun 2024 19:29:55
Exactly Pinball, why would Toronto need a top 2 right handed defenseman and a top 6 winger when they could keep an overpaid top line winger and a bottom pair right handed defenseman?
Its not like having a a 40-50 point right handed defenseman and a 40-50 point right winger is going to improve the Leafs. They're better off trying to trade both their pending RFAs and their 1st round pick for a 32 year old Cam Fowler with a no movement clause.
3.) 05 Jun 2024 20:25:37
I am a Leaf fan Pinball and I do that trade without thinking twice. Helps to get the Leafs out of cap hell, improves the team defense and Garland can improve in a new setting. Teams are not lining up to help the Leafs so most likely they will have to lose a little in an effort to trade him.
4.) 05 Jun 2024 21:02:49
Quiet Guy
Marner will not be traded, everyone seems to forget a few things.
First of all Treliving isn't trading an elite forward for a package like that, he is too smart to pull that proposal, Treliving is looking to get better not worse and trading Marner doesn't make them better.
Second Marner has stated he is playing out his final year of his contract with TORONTO, he has a NMC in his contract and he has complete control of being traded.
Thirdly The Leafs have 19,405.333 million in Cap Space to improve, players like Cowan, Grebyonkin and Quillan or Minton are options at forward if they focus on Defense and or Goaltending.
Marner didn't have a very good playoff we all know that, but in the previous playoffs he did perform.
Trust me when I say Marner won't be traded, he won't.
5.) 05 Jun 2024 22:21:43
I never said they would trade him. but if they don't or can't they won't improve. So as long as your good with 1st round exits that will keep ya happy I guess.
6.) 05 Jun 2024 23:14:22
If you're so sure Marner won't be traded, then why were you trying to convince everyone on here that Marner would be trade to Ottawa for Chychrun, Pinto and the 7th overall pick?
Or that he would be traded to Anaheim for Carlsson, Strome, and the 3rd overall pick?
Or that he would be traded to Utah for Keller, Schmaltz, Ingram and the 6th overall pick?
You were pretty insecure and stressed out when everyone disagreed that any of those 3 trades could happen.
I agree with Quiet Guy. He's a smarter Leafs fan than you and is pretty realistic about what the actual return for Marner would be.
7.) 06 Jun 2024 01:39:51
Quiet Guy
It has been confirmed in the last 24 hours Treliving isn't looking to make a trade to just make a trade, and Marner with a NMC isn't give his 8 team trade list available, and also confirmed he will honor his contract for The Leafs.
Treliving will improve this team I truly believe that, Toronto didn't win or lose because of Marner it's still a team game not a one player sport.
8.) 06 Jun 2024 21:20:50
Another assumption by you. Never said he was at fault. Said they are in cap hell and one of the big contracts needs to go and Marner is the most logical. But keep spinning things Pinball.
9.) 11 Jun 2024 04:36:29
Hey Pinball
Treliving traded M Tkachuk for Huberdeau. never say never.
01 Jun 2024 19:06:50
Saros, Lauzon and Novak for Marner, Liljegren and Jarnkrok?
1.) 01 Jun 2024 20:36:46
Sorry, forgot to add Toronto sending a 2nd rounder.
2.) 03 Jun 2024 21:09:50
overpayment from the Leafs, Marner could probably fetch Saros and Novak himself. Lauzon is probably worth a mid draft pick
06 Mar 2024 20:18:08
To Toronto- Parayko and Neighbours
To Blues - Brodie, Minten, Niemela and 2024 first
blues could then flip Brodie for a pick with some retention.
1.) 07 Mar 2024 12:57:29
I watched the Blues a couple days after making a Parayko trade and he’s still a horse. the contract is a little scary but he’s solid out there.
Neighbours was also one of the best Blues players out there, I’m guessing he’s next to untouchable.
2.) 07 Mar 2024 13:22:36
That doesnt get you parayko not at all. Neighbors isn't for sale. Why would anyone do that?
15 Sep 2024 16:57:59
Oilers say no easily.
02 Aug 2024 20:45:57
Only difference being the 2 leafs nhl players pinball suggests are better than the players you put in for SJ, and the 3 all players are better as well.
Yours is worse than the bad deal pinball suggests.
02 Aug 2024 20:43:24
Why engage. Pinballs offer was bad. we all know it. If No one responds he is less likely to post. And yes this is terrible for Toronto.
28 Jul 2024 20:10:35
OK. so what if it's a sign and trade do they give more? Laine and his contract is a negative remember.
02 Jul 2024 17:28:37
Anaheim takes that in a heartbeat. There still won't be a deal as Toronto just signed Lilly. Be hard pressed to trade him so fast.
Quiet Guy has no Banter Replies