NHL Trade Rumors Member Posts

 

Flyers2893's Profile

Current Avatar:
No Avatar image uploaded

No Profile Picture uploaded

Team:


Where from:


Favourite player:


Best team moment:


Interests:


Timezone:




Flyers2893's Posts and Other Poster's Replies To Flyers2893's Posts

 

 

To Flyers2893's last 5 rumours posts

 

To Flyers2893's last 5 rumour replies

 

Flyers2893's rumours posts with other poster's replies to Flyers2893's rumours posts

 

06 Nov 2017 18:23:59
After my failure of a trade proposal somebody mentioned a little switch that I thought didn't look bad. Would this work or still way off

PHI: Simmonds, STL 1st round pick

WPG: Trouba, 3rd round pick

Same reasons as before

Is Trouba's value pretty much normal a year after his little dilemma

Flyers2893

1.) 06 Nov 2017 19:14:59
Winnipeg doesn't need simmonds. They want a left hand defencemen


2.) 06 Nov 2017 21:02:10
Nope. As I said the Jets won't be able to afford Simmonds after this contract is up and don't really need any wingers.


3.) 06 Nov 2017 21:08:48
Super young Simmonds that Winnypeg absolutely needs!


4.) 06 Nov 2017 23:18:39
Nope. Jets still won't be able to fit Simmonds' contract in when it is up and they don't really need more wingers.


 

 

06 Nov 2017 14:40:29
I look at what just went down with the Duchene trade and I look back at last years Hanzal trade. Two similar cases the Flyers have contract wise are Simmonds and Filppula. While age is a factor Simmonds is on a better contract than Duchene and isn't asking for a trade. Filppula is actually playing really good on pace to be better than Hanzal was. So basing off of history I've proposed these two deals

PHI Receives: Trouba, 1st round pick

WPG Receives: Simmonds, 3rd round pick

Philadelphia does this because Simmonds is a free agent in two years and will have to earn big money. With all the younger guys they'll have to pay, his contract might hurt them. They also only have one right handed d-man prospect and one right handed d-man on the team right now

Winnipeg does this because who knows how Trouba will be when it comes to an extensions after last time. Also, they are pretty stacked at defense and I see Simmonds fitting in their middle 6 easily

Trade 2

PHI Receives: 2nd round pick

LAK or CBJ Receives: Filppula 50% retained

Philly does for the sole purpose of getting something for a player I doubt they'll bring back. If he keeps producing the way he is either they might not want to trade him or he can possibly get more but I thought a second round pick was reasonable. Or is it too high? TBH I don't even know

LA or CBJ do it for pretty much the same reason. They both have a good goalie with a decent defense and should be looking to do good in the playoffs. LA might need him more with Carter injured but both teams add some center depth

Thoughts? Am I way off here?

Flyers2893

1.) 06 Nov 2017 16:20:36
Switch the picks in the first trade. Defenseman have way more value than wingers.


2.) 06 Nov 2017 16:27:03
Yeah, you are waaaaay off. No, way two years of Simmonds gets you Trouba. Simmonds is a good player, but the Jets would be in the same position in two years having to pay him when they can't afford him. Not to mention a middle 6 player isn't going to get you a young 1-2D.


3.) 06 Nov 2017 18:11:09
I agree the first trade doesn’t work for jets, but I wouldn’t call Simmons a middle six player. 28, 29, 31, 32 goals over last 4 seasons. That’s a top line forward on almost any team, but I would accept top 6. But not middle six. Not a 2nd-3rd liner.


4.) 06 Nov 2017 18:15:20
Btw, what was Trouba's value when there were trade rumors about him.


5.) 07 Nov 2017 01:54:49
Probably should have thought of that Hall for Larsson trade before posting. Guess this was a swing and a miss. How bout the second trade though?


 

 

15 Oct 2017 18:39:17
PHI: Morin, Filppula, Weise, STL 1st round pick

MTL: Galchenyuk

Value wise I think this is very similar to the Schenn trade but the Flyers role is flipped

Philadelphia gets rid of a NHL ready d-man who speaks French which we all know Montreal likes. He's outgrown the AHL and due to lineup decisions and the amount of young defensemen we have he's wasting his time in the AHL. Filppula is a rental who could potentially be resigned. I believe he would be the second best center on Montreal behind Drouin. Don't believe he'll score as much as Drouin but he'll make up for a good chunk of that this year. I threw I Weise because he was great with Montreal so he could always go back there and do good. Not much risk there. And then the first round pick to make up the difference. Getting rid of two forwards and getting one back not only lessens the log jam but they get more talented

As for Montreal, they are getting rid of a guy who is performing to their expectations but who is still young and has potential. They'll be improving their defense. Not really smart to get rid of offense when they need it but they are getting a little bit of offense in return

Overall, I wouldn't want Philly to get rid of Morin since he's really different than their other young d-men. I also don't think Montreal should give up on Galchenyuk right away. But I wanted to take a crack at it anyways

Flyers2893

1.) 15 Oct 2017 21:34:55
canadiens laugh.


2.) 15 Oct 2017 21:37:58
so basically 2 cap dumps and an ahl player and a low first delusional af.


3.) 15 Oct 2017 21:57:52
flyers received the best player on that schenn deal wtf is this shit.


4.) 16 Oct 2017 01:46:55
I love how you include “who speaks French” hahahahahahah.


5.) 16 Oct 2017 05:24:31
@MTL4LIFE I totally get you disagreeing with the proposal because everybody has their opinion. I've been wrong in the past, will be wrong in the future and could very well be wrong now. But I just feel the need to correct your reasoning. First off, I'm hoping you meant something else, but the Flyers did not receive the best player in the Schenn deal.

He is better than Lehtera and will most likely be better than the individual first round picks. Secondly Morin isn't an AHL player. He's NHL ready, everybody says it, look it up if you want. He's just blocked by the other young defensemen Philly has. You don't want him sitting in the press box thus the reason they sent him down. Saying he's an AHLer is like me calling Galchenyuk a 4th liner because he was on it last game. You were 100% correct about the first round pick.

IMO you were 50% correct about the other 2. Weise is a cap dump but the destination is key. The only place he did good in was Montreal. Maybe it's a team thing. But if you have no interest in taking a chance on him it's very understandable. As for Filppula I wouldn't call him a cap dump. I believe he got like 42 points last year. Would have got a couple more if he played every game.

For 5 mil, it could be an overpayment but far from a cap dump. Galchenyuk got 44 points last year (I think) but was on pace for 59, which is better but not exactly blowing Filppula out of the waters. Filppula also adds a two way game though. Besides, it's not like Chuky is lighting the lamp this year. 1 goal to Filppula's 3.

Not saying he's the worse player but just try not to use the term cap dump as loosely. Especially considering he has 1 year left and could be resigned for cheaper. But everybody has their opinion so I'll leave it at that.


6.) 16 Oct 2017 00:11:08
Mtl4life how did the flyers get the best player in the schenn trade? Please, elaborate. i don't know why montreals so offended from this offer, galchenyuk isn't worth a 1st alone.


7.) 16 Oct 2017 06:35:59
MTL4LIFE was just owned.
Nice one Flyers2893. That was great.


8.) 16 Oct 2017 13:27:11
got his ass whooped there LOL

Not a bad trade, if the habs believe that morin can become a good d for them then it would be worth it, filp is a good player who as you said is a rental, so that 5 mil won't be a problem, weise was great for the habs, if they want to take a chance on a guy i say he'd be the one. AND a first, just saw that. yeah this is definitely a fair deal. Good going Flyers!


 

 

04 Jun 2017 02:24:33
Boston: Debrusk, 1st round pick

Philadelphia: Schenn, 3rd round pick

Thoughts on the value?

Flyers2893

1.) 04 Jun 2017 12:21:15
I'm keeping Schenn on the Flyers.


2.) 04 Jun 2017 15:10:22
Would rather keep Schenn.


3.) 04 Jun 2017 23:13:59
I'd stay with Schenn.


 

 

29 May 2017 11:53:01
Canucks: Tanev

Flyers: Sanheim, 3rd round pick

Flyers get a top 4 right handed d-man and the Canucks get a potential top 4 d-man to help with their rebuild and a draft pick

Who adds?

Flyers2893

1.) 03 Jun 2017 15:25:03
Potential top 4 in Sanheim? Try potential top 2. Not giving a 3rd and Sanheim for a 28 y/ o defenseman the Flyers don't need. Flyers have a RHD defenseman close to being in philly.


 

 

 

Flyers2893 has no Talk Posts

 

 

Flyers2893's rumour replies

 

Click To View This Thread

07 Nov 2017 01:54:49
Probably should have thought of that Hall for Larsson trade before posting. Guess this was a swing and a miss. How bout the second trade though?

Flyers2893

 

 

Click To View This Thread

06 Nov 2017 18:15:20
Btw, what was Trouba's value when there were trade rumors about him.

Flyers2893

 

 

Click To View This Thread

16 Oct 2017 05:24:31
@MTL4LIFE I totally get you disagreeing with the proposal because everybody has their opinion. I've been wrong in the past, will be wrong in the future and could very well be wrong now. But I just feel the need to correct your reasoning. First off, I'm hoping you meant something else, but the Flyers did not receive the best player in the Schenn deal.

He is better than Lehtera and will most likely be better than the individual first round picks. Secondly Morin isn't an AHL player. He's NHL ready, everybody says it, look it up if you want. He's just blocked by the other young defensemen Philly has. You don't want him sitting in the press box thus the reason they sent him down. Saying he's an AHLer is like me calling Galchenyuk a 4th liner because he was on it last game. You were 100% correct about the first round pick.

IMO you were 50% correct about the other 2. Weise is a cap dump but the destination is key. The only place he did good in was Montreal. Maybe it's a team thing. But if you have no interest in taking a chance on him it's very understandable. As for Filppula I wouldn't call him a cap dump. I believe he got like 42 points last year. Would have got a couple more if he played every game.

For 5 mil, it could be an overpayment but far from a cap dump. Galchenyuk got 44 points last year (I think) but was on pace for 59, which is better but not exactly blowing Filppula out of the waters. Filppula also adds a two way game though. Besides, it's not like Chuky is lighting the lamp this year. 1 goal to Filppula's 3.

Not saying he's the worse player but just try not to use the term cap dump as loosely. Especially considering he has 1 year left and could be resigned for cheaper. But everybody has their opinion so I'll leave it at that.

Flyers2893

 

 

Click To View This Thread

04 Jun 2017 14:25:37
First round pick would do IMO, although since it's 11th overall that seems a bit high too.

Flyers2893

 

 

Click To View This Thread

21 May 2017 16:45:34
@vbbbvvbb the second overall pick is not involved in the deal. It's next years 1st round pick

Flyers2893

 

 

 

Flyers2893 has no Talk Replies